June 9, 2026 · Youth Development · 10 min read
Youth Development
Sport is widely assumed to develop character, teamwork and social skills in young people. The evidence is more conditional than this. Sport produces these outcomes under specific conditions and fails to under others.
The belief that sport builds character and develops social skills in young people is deeply embedded in most cultures. Parents, policymakers and youth development practitioners across the Gulf, Africa, Asia and Europe hold this belief. It shapes investment in sport programmes as a youth development tool. It is also partially correct and partially not, in ways that matter for anyone designing or running sport-based youth programmes.
The research on sport and youth development is clear that sport can be a powerful context for developing social skills, emotional regulation, resilience, teamwork and leadership in young people. It is equally clear that sport does not automatically produce these outcomes. Whether sport produces positive developmental outcomes depends significantly on how sport programmes are designed, what the adult environment surrounding the sport provides, and what the quality of coaching and facilitation is. Sport in a poorly designed programme with an autocratic, win-at-all-costs coaching culture can produce the opposite of the intended outcomes: increased aggression, decreased empathy, and reinforcement of unhealthy attitudes about competition and winning.
Key Takeaways
Research on youth sport shows that programme design and interpersonal climate matter. A 2024 systematic review and meta-analysis of coach- and parent-development programmes found small to medium effects on a subset of youth-athlete outcomes, including task-related climate, enjoyment and anxiety, while noting that the intervention evidence base remains limited.
A 2025 meta-analysis of 177 studies also found a positive association between motivational climate and youth-sport outcomes, but with substantial heterogeneity across outcomes and studies. That supports treating coaching climate as an important design factor without turning it into one guaranteed effect size.
Source: systematic review and meta-analysis of motivational climate and youth sport outcomes
Supportive coach and adult relationships are an important part of many positive-youth-development models, but they are one part of a wider programme environment that also includes peer climate, opportunities for participation, safeguarding and the way skills are facilitated. Sport can provide a setting in which these relationships develop; it should not be treated as the sole causal mechanism.
Physical-activity participation varies substantially across Gulf countries, sex, age and study. Programme designers should assess barriers such as climate, transport, facilities, cost, family support, safety and social norms in the specific community rather than assuming one Gulf-wide pattern.
Saudi sport policy has expanded participation opportunities, including for women and girls. For programme designers, the useful implication is to verify the current local participation environment, facilities and safeguarding requirements rather than relying on assumptions formed before recent policy changes. Policy expansion itself should not be treated as proof of a particular youth-development outcome.
Youth workers and programme designers in Gulf contexts need to design sport-based development programmes that address the specific barriers to physical activity in their communities, that engage family systems rather than treating young people in isolation from them, and that are culturally adapted for the specific community. Matsh’s Youth and Healthy Lifestyle Promotion course addresses these design requirements directly.
Sport is used as a youth development tool across Africa in a wide variety of contexts from NGO-run community programmes to government youth development schemes. The research base on African sport-for-development programmes is more limited than the global evidence base. Community engagement, facilitator quality and safe, inclusive delivery should be tested in the local programme context rather than assumed to produce one fixed effect across African settings.
The resourcing context of sport-for-development in many African settings creates specific design challenges. Programmes with minimal equipment and facilities can still produce strong developmental outcomes if coaching quality and programme design are prioritised. Low-resource sport programmes still need capable facilitators, safe delivery and appropriate programme design, but the available evidence does not justify one universal claim that facilitator investment is always more important than physical resources. Matsh’s Working with Young People in Their Communities course builds the facilitation and programme design skills for these contexts.
No fixed multiplier
Mastery/task-oriented climates are generally associated with more positive youth outcomes, but effect sizes vary by outcome and study.
Varies by study
Physical-activity participation varies across Gulf countries, sex, age and study; use current country-level surveillance when a numeric comparison is needed.
Policy context
Saudi sport investment is policy context, not evidence of a youth-development outcome.
Build Youth Programme Design Skills for Your Context
Matsh’s youth development courses address sport-based and community-based programme design for Gulf and African contexts. See also our related analysis of youth empowerment frameworks.
Translating the research findings on sport and youth development into programme design produces a specific set of requirements that most sport-for-development programmes do not fully meet. These are not complex. They are not expensive. They are consistently underinvested in because they require sustained attention to implementation rather than a single upfront design decision.
Coaching and interpersonal climate are important programme-design levers, but the available evidence does not justify one universal ‘highest-return’ investment claim. This means regularly assessing whether coaches are creating mastery-oriented or performance-comparison climates, providing ongoing coaching development rather than one-time training, and building feedback mechanisms that surface problems in coaching practice before they produce harm. None of this is difficult. All of it requires sustained organisational attention.
Social skills do not develop automatically through sport participation. They develop when sport programmes explicitly design for it: creating structured reflection time after matches and training sessions, assigning specific social skill development objectives to each programme phase, using peer coaching and facilitated discussion as teaching tools, and measuring social skill development alongside sporting performance. The design elements are teachable and learnable. Matsh’s Working with Young People in Their Communities course builds these design skills specifically.
Family and community engagement may be useful where those relationships affect participation, safety, transport, expectations or continuity. Programme teams should decide what involvement is appropriate from local evidence and participant needs rather than assume a uniform Gulf- or Africa-wide effect.
In Gulf contexts, programme designers should assess how family support, safety, transport, cost and local norms affect participation in the specific community rather than assuming one region-wide retention effect. This is not a cultural accommodation. It is a programme design requirement in contexts where family systems shape young people’s choices.
| Design Element | High-Quality Programme | Low-Quality Programme |
|---|---|---|
| Coaching climate | Mastery-focused; effort and improvement valued | Winning-focused; performance comparison drives culture |
| Social skill development | Explicitly designed in; structured reflection and facilitated discussion | Assumed to happen automatically through participation |
| Coach relationship | Trusted adult relationship; consistent, caring, high-expectation | Transactional; focused on technique delivery |
| Family engagement | Structured and intentional; families understand programme goals | Incidental or absent; families treated as logistical participants |
Saudi Arabia’s Vision 2030 created a policy environment for youth sport-based development programmes that simply did not exist before 2017. The physical infrastructure investment, including the construction of community sports facilities across the Kingdom, has created programme delivery capacity that organisations can now access. More significantly, the cultural shift that has expanded what is socially acceptable for young Saudis, particularly young Saudi women, in sport and physical activity contexts has opened programme design space that practitioners are still working out how to use effectively.
The programmes that are navigating this environment most successfully are those that work with families and community structures rather than assuming that regulatory permission automatically translates into family and community willingness. The gap between what is legally possible and what families in specific communities will support remains significant in many contexts, and programmes that ignore this gap have higher dropout rates than those that actively address it.
Does sport automatically develop social skills in young people?
No. Sport participation does not automatically produce social skill development. The outcomes depend significantly on programme design specifically, the coaching climate, whether social skill development is explicitly facilitated, and the quality of the adult relationship. Sport in programmes with poor coaching cultures can produce negative developmental outcomes including increased aggression and unhealthy attitudes about competition. Well-designed programmes with quality facilitation and explicit social skill development produce consistent positive outcomes.
Why are physical activity rates low among young people in Gulf countries?
Physical activity levels among Gulf youth are often reported as low in available studies, driven by several converging factors: climate that makes outdoor activity uncomfortable for much of the year, urban environments designed around car transport rather than active movement, social norms in some communities around visible physical activity, and strong competition from indoor entertainment. Vision 2030 is investing in expanding sport and physical activity participation, including specifically for women and girls, but uptake has been uneven across regions and socioeconomic groups.
How should sport-based youth programmes be designed for maximum developmental impact?
Sport-based youth development programmes produce the best outcomes when: coaching climate emphasises mastery and personal growth rather than performance comparison and winning; social skill development is explicitly facilitated rather than assumed; the adult-youth relationship is prioritised and coaches are trained in relationship-based development approaches; family and community systems are engaged as partners; and cultural context is addressed specifically rather than applying generic frameworks. These design principles apply across Gulf, African and Asian contexts, with specific adaptations required for each.
What is the impact of Vision 2030 on sport and youth development in Saudi Arabia?
Vision 2030 has significantly expanded sport participation opportunities in Saudi Arabia, including opening sport to women and girls at scale in ways that were significantly restricted before 2017. This has created genuinely new programme design opportunities for youth development practitioners. Approaches designed on pre-2020 assumptions about what is available or appropriate for young Saudi women are now outdated. Youth workers need to design for the current reality, including navigating uneven adoption of the changes across regions and socioeconomic contexts.
Build Youth Development Skills for Gulf and African Contexts
Matsh’s youth development courses are built for the specific contexts where participants work, not adapted from Western frameworks.
Related Matsh Courses
We run all our courses as private programmes for organisations across the GCC and Africa.
Request In-House →